700k budget: 04 BMW Msport, 09 2.0LForester, 09 GTA? URGENT!

Hi guys,

I'm about to finalize in buying the 2004 BMW 318 MSPORT tomorrow, would you prefer buying a different one?

2004 BMW 318 MSPORT
- previous owner: my uncle (2nd hand)
- Mileage: 40k
- no engine problems, change in transmission valve only

2009 Subaru Forester 2.0L
- AutoCamp Ortigas
- Price: ~800k
- Mileage: 52k
- Casa maintained

I've seen in sulit that 2009 GT-A is also being sold around this price range as well.

Which one would you prefer? Since I'm buying a 2nd hand car.. I'm leaning more towards in buying the MSPORT. Since it's my uncle and I trust it's history.

But the Forester is very tempting also.. and since it's casa-maintained, the history should also be trusted?

Need your feedbacks asap!

Thanks!